Georgie Mears has been found guilty of murdering 17-year-old Tristan Kerr in a fatal stabbing at a house in Abertridwr, Caerphilly, on Thursday, February 5. The verdict was delivered at Newport Crown Court on Wednesday afternoon following a trial that began on October 5, with the jury also finding Connor Palfrey, 24, not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter. Ricardo Elliot, 26, and Elexi Manny, 24, were acquitted of both murder and manslaughter charges. Daily Dazzling Dawn understands the courtroom fell silent as the verdicts were read, with a single sob heard from the public gallery when Mears was convicted.
Neither Mears nor Palfrey was present in court to hear the verdicts. Mrs Justice Mary Stacey informed the court that both men were suffering from a sickness bug in custody. The jury, described by the judge as "the most fantastic jury imaginable," had retired to deliberate on Tuesday before returning their verdicts on Wednesday afternoon. Sentencing for Mears and Palfrey has been scheduled for Wednesday, November 18. The judge thanked counsel and the public gallery for the composure they demonstrated throughout the emotionally charged proceedings.
The court heard that Tristan Kerr was playing Fortnite with friends at a property on Lower Francis Street when the defendants arrived at approximately 5.40pm. The prosecution, led by Michael Jones KC, told jurors that Mears entered the living room armed with a Rambo-style hunting knife while Palfrey carried a wooden stick. The attack was described as "immediate and purposeful," with the blade passing through the teenager's lung and heart. The entire incident lasted less than two minutes.
Daily Dazzling Dawn learned during the trial that Mears shouted "what, what, what?" as he entered the property and was "acting like a gangster" before directing Tristan towards him. Palfrey allegedly brandished the wooden weapon to deter Tristan's friends from intervening, warning them not to get involved. The prosecution asserted that the group had spent the day before the incident driving around Cardiff and Caerphilly in Manny's car collecting drug debts.
After being stabbed, Tristan managed to flee the property with his friend Conah Davies. The court heard harrowing details of the teenager's final moments as he attempted to escape through the back of the house. Ring doorbell footage showed Tristan trying to steady himself on a bin before collapsing beside a parked car.
Prosecutor Michael Jones KC told the jury that Tristan said to his friend: "Custard, I'm hurting, my side." He then added: "I love you bro, you're a good 'un you are." Sobs could be heard from the public gallery as these words were read aloud during the trial. Tristan collapsed two more times before Mr Davies ran back to the house to retrieve a phone. When he returned, he held Tristan in his lap, but the teenager had stopped communicating. He died at the scene shortly afterwards from the catastrophic injury to his chest.
Following the stabbing, the four defendants allegedly left the house together and drove away in Manny's vehicle. The court heard they travelled to Hereford, where Mears was seen being sick out of the back of a Volkswagen Polo driven by Manny. The prosecution had alleged that Manny acted as the group's getaway driver while Elliot served as a lookout. Their defence teams characterised the prosecution's case as "desperately flawed," and both were subsequently cleared of all charges.
Mears, of Cavendish Close in Thornhill, Cardiff, had admitted stabbing the teenager but maintained he acted in self-defence, alleging that Tristan attacked him first. Palfrey, of Aberfawr Terrace in Abertridwr, told jurors he went into the house empty-handed and picked up a stick inside the property. He described the atmosphere as tense, stating that Tristan and Mears started "bickering" before a fight broke out.
Tristan Kerr was a talented rugby player whose death has left his family and friends devastated. The case has deeply affected the tight-knit former mining community of Abertridwr. Mrs Justice Stacey directed the jury that unanimous verdicts were required for each defendant, asking them to consider whether the Crown had proved that each shared an intention to cause Tristan at least really serious harm.
Daily Dazzling Dawn will continue to follow this case and report further developments as sentencing approaches on November 18.