Proceedings on Day 6 of the trial into the death of 16-year-old Chloe Watson Dransfield have been delayed until approximately 2pm on Tuesday, November 17, as co-defendants prepare to open their defence at Leeds Crown Court.
The judge sat at 11:03am and called the case on before informing jurors at 11:06am that the trial was not in a position to get under way immediately and would resume later in the afternoon.
Chloe, from Gomersal, died after being found with fatal stab wounds on Kennerleigh Avenue in Austhorpe, Leeds, at around 6am on Saturday, March 28. Kayla Smith, 18, of Kennerleigh Avenue, initially admitted manslaughter on Day 1 of the trial before changing her plea on Day 3 to admit Chloe's murder. Co-defendants Archie Rycroft, 20, of Middleton Park Road, and Blake Dowling, 18, deny murder charges and are standing trial in proceedings expected to last four weeks.
Prosecutor Mark McKone KC is expected to read a set of agreed facts to the jury before the defence begins presenting its case. Both Blake Dowling and Archie Rycroft are scheduled to take the witness stand, while mobile and CCTV timeline analyst Joshua Gladwin—who concluded his evidence on Monday—is also due to answer questions from the defence.
On Monday, November 16, forensic speech and audio specialist Dr Catherine Earnshaw, director at the Forensic Voice Centre, gave evidence on 22 recordings recovered from the scene—including a 3:45am Ring doorbell clip. Using specialist software to reduce background noise and increase speech clarity, she enhanced 12 of the clips. Dr Earnshaw confirmed she was given no background information about the case or the names of those involved beforehand, and noted that several recordings contained no audible speech or unintelligible passages, while speech was less clear over courtroom speakers than on headphones.
In a clip beginning at 5:10am, a female voice identified as Kayla Smith was heard saying "go" or "come then," "come on big girl, come on," "come on, come on, come on, come on then," and "I will stab you," before stating at 5:11am: "I'm gonna stab you." A distant second female voice, taken to be Chloe Dransfield, was heard saying "What, what, what, what, what" alongside unintelligible speech, while a male voice said "Chill," another laughed, and a male possibly said, "Oh you stabbed her."
Further audio captured the immediate aftermath of the attack. At 5:12am, after a male voice said "She's fully stabbed her," a voice identified as Archie Rycroft replied "I know" and, following laughter, added: "She wasn't joking... stabbed her straight up."
Later clips included a voice identified as Blake Dowling saying, "You've killed her, on ma's life you've killed her" and "On my mam's life you've killed her stone-dead." Smith responded, "No I ant killed her, how have I killed her?" and told grandfather Geoffrey Smith, "No you can't ring the police she's dead." Another recording captured Dowling saying Chloe was "on the floor, foaming at the mouth," followed by a male asking, "Who's ringing me a taxi? Archie ring me a taxi." Earlier references in court also pointed to McDonald's footage and a message from a male stating: "A bird I'm with has just stabbed another bird up."
Jurors also heard timeline and CCTV evidence covering the hours after the stabbing. At 6:11am, footage showed Blake Dowling and two males arriving by taxi at one of their homes. According to Mr McKone, they entered through the front gate and walked down the side of the house, where another male took an item from his left trouser pocket and passed it to Dowling, put on Dowling's puffa jacket, removed an item from it, used his phone, picked up keys thrown from an upstairs window, and went inside followed by Dowling and the other male.
Between 6:15am and 6:22am, Geoffrey Smith walked back up the drive with a police officer, followed by two officers, toward the summerhouse. Kayla Smith opened the curtains slightly, closed them, and eventually opened the door. At 6:22am, officers spoke with Geoffrey Smith as he came from the garden and back gate direction while an ambulance drove past.
Later in the morning, Geoffrey Smith was seen on camera with a dog beside the house at 6:45am, and call data at 6:49am showed Kayla Smith's phone had returned to the LS15 postcode and been activated. At 7:13am, Kayla Smith walked out of the property with two officers while Geoffrey Smith stood by the side door, with Smith heard saying, "Getting arrested."
Addressing motion-activated cameras, witness VS confirmed under questioning by Ms Batts that cameras next to Kayla Smith's house and along the drive failed to trigger and record at times despite movement taking place.
Last week, Mr McKone opened the prosecution case and called witnesses including friends of Chloe, a forensic scientist, a pathologist, and Mr Gladwin, who compiled mobile data and CCTV footage into a chronology. Mr McKone also noted that Chloe's friend tried to call her at 8:03am on March 28.