.svg)
Immigration continues to be one of the most hotly debated topics globally, often stirring passionate opinions about its effects on society, the economy, and politics. But what does the evidence actually say? These seven recent studies provide a data-backed perspective on how immigration shapes the lives of both migrants and host communities—from mental health outcomes and nationalist attitudes to crime rates and conspiracy beliefs.
1. Immigrants in the U.S. Show Lower Rates of Psychiatric Disorders Compared to Natives
A comprehensive study in Psychiatry Research analyzed data from over 36,000 adults and found that immigrants in the United States are significantly less likely to suffer from anxiety, depression, or trauma-related disorders than those born in the U.S. Even when adjusting for demographics and family history, immigrants showed stronger mental resilience—supporting the "healthy migrant hypothesis," which suggests that people who migrate tend to be healthier and more psychologically robust than non-migrants.The effect was most notable among those who migrated after age 12 and applied to immigrants from Africa, Asia, Europe, and Latin America. However, individuals who migrated as children showed mental health profiles more similar to U.S.-born individuals, likely due to early exposure to American social stressors, including discrimination.
2. Immigration Uncertainty Fuels Nationalist Sentiment in Portugal
Research published in the Journal of Social and Political Psychology found that uncertainty surrounding immigration leads to stronger nationalist attitudes in Portugal. When people felt unclear about the impact of immigration, they were more likely to see migrants as economic or cultural threats—especially in terms of jobs and public resources.Two separate studies showed that these economic concerns drove nationalist views more than cultural fears, highlighting the role of material insecurity in shaping attitudes toward immigration in economically strained contexts.
3. Social Media Heightens Anti-Immigrant Emotions Among Lower Cognitive Ability Users
A study in Frontiers in Psychology revealed that social media amplifies negative sentiments about immigrants—particularly among users with lower cognitive ability. Analyzing over 86,000 online posts from Singapore, researchers found that immigration-related discussions were more emotionally charged and negative than other topics.A follow-up survey of over 1,000 Singaporeans confirmed that heavy social media users who viewed immigrants as threats experienced stronger feelings of anger and fear. Those with lower cognitive skills were more vulnerable to such reactions, likely due to difficulty processing complex information or resisting misinformation. By contrast, individuals with higher cognitive ability were less emotionally influenced.
4. Stricter U.S. Immigration Policies Did Not Lower Crime Rates Among Immigrants
A study in Crime & Delinquency challenged the notion that tougher immigration laws reduce crime. Examining arrest records in California and Texas between 2015 and 2018—during the Trump administration’s crackdown on immigration—researchers found no significant change in immigrant crime rates.Immigrants consistently showed lower arrest rates than non-immigrants, especially for violent crimes. Slight declines in property and traffic offenses mirrored broader trends and weren’t unique to immigrants. The findings suggest that harsh immigration policies had little effect on public safety and that immigrants are not major contributors to crime.
5. High-Skilled Immigrants Spur Entrepreneurship in U.S. Cities
According to a study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, high-skilled immigration, especially through H-1B visas, is associated with greater entrepreneurial activity in U.S. metropolitan areas. A doubling of new H-1B arrivals was linked to a 6% rise in new business formation within three years.The effect was limited to newcomers, not existing residents or low-skilled visa holders, and was most pronounced in areas with strong immigrant communities and large firms. The researchers suggest that workplace knowledge-sharing and immigrant networks likely play a role in boosting entrepreneurship, even if these immigrants aren’t starting businesses themselves.
6. One in Three Americans Endorses “White Replacement” Beliefs, Tied to Antisocial Traits
A nationally representative survey published in Politics, Groups, and Identities found that about 33% of Americans believe in some version of the “White Replacement” theory—the idea that white Americans are being replaced by immigrants through intentional policies.Interestingly, belief in this theory wasn’t strongly tied to political affiliation. Instead, it was associated with psychological traits like authoritarianism, antisocial behavior, and distrust of institutions. Those who held such beliefs were also more likely to harbor negative views of minorities and women, spread misinformation, and express support for political violence—especially among frequent consumers of fringe media.
7. Replacement Narratives and Status Threats Increase Support for Political Violence
A follow-up study in Preventive Medicine Reports explored the connection between belief in “White Replacement” theory, perceived social disadvantage, and support for political violence. Surveying nearly 6,000 white Americans, researchers found that those endorsing these beliefs were more than twice as likely to justify political violence.Low income, lack of education, and feelings of racial isolation also played a role, particularly for white men and women in racially homogeneous neighborhoods. Support for violence was highest at the extremes—among those in mostly white or mostly non-white areas. This research highlights how ideological and social factors can combine to fuel radicalization.
_1.jpg)
